Causer Fons

Contributor to dialogues, participation in the public square, digital era community

The irony of Proof-of-Work ID and BitCoin

I signed up for the bitcoin forum (https://bitcointalk.org) in order to participate in the debates there about the status and future of our beloved peer-to-peer currency.

However, they have a newbie policy which restricts the ability to post until you have been logged in for 4 hours and made 5 posts to the newbie section.

No criticism against the managers of the forum for having such a policy, their motivation is clear and it may be effective  in limiting spam, trolling and other noise..

I guess one can safely regard sitting by ones computer for 4 hours and posting 5 newbie-posts as “proof-of-work”?

However, isn’t it ironic that a forum dedicated to a currency which is designed with proof-of-work at its core does not have access to an ID and credential-forming mechanism which uses proof-or-work in a more sophisticated way to filter out noise?

There are at least two immediately apparent ways more sophisticated proof of work could be implemented to filter noise:

(A) every newbie could be forced to make a quasi-anonymous bitcoin donation to the forum, which is confiscated in case a user is banned, or redeemed to the user once a probationary period is over and he/she has established a valuable profile;

(B) a more sophisticated and universal ID mechanism using public-key cryptography, a-la the BTC network but with ID as its fundamental “currency unit”, could be developed to allow for access to the BTC forum and other similar forums, in this case when the user presents an “anonymous” credential their proof of work would be the value ascribed to the ID based on their behavior and access privileges across different sites and services – such a network does not exist yet, to my knowledge, but is an extremely interesting proposition..?

CF

I am

The below public key defines who I am

—–BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK—–
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
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=d7/R
—–END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK—–